Behind the Mask, Beside Each Other: two reflections on Spider-Man: Brand New Day
This one is for the Spider-Man fans. ❤️
If Spider-Man has ever felt a little more personal than a superhero should, this one is for you. What follows is a conversation between two people who found something of themselves in the same story. The first piece was written by someone who chose to stay behind the mask. The second is my response to it, not to correct him or to speak over him, but to sit beside his words for a while.
The Boy the World Forgot: What Spider-Man: Brand New Day Taught Me About Losing Myself
There’s a version of Peter Parker that most of us remember, the high school kid who couldn’t stop smiling, who couldn’t stop helping, who wore his heart on the outside because he didn’t know any other way to be. Charismatic without trying. Kind without calculating. The boy everyone wanted at their table.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day isn’t about that boy. It’s about what happens after him. By the time we meet Peter again, something has shifted. The world he once saved has moved on without him. The people he once stood in front of, shielded, bled for, they’ve forgotten. Not out of cruelty. Just the quiet, ordinary cruelty of time. He’s still fighting. He’s still showing up. But nobody’s counting anymore, and somewhere along the way, the mask stopped being something he put on and started being something he lives inside of.
He loses the people who loved him, not to tragedy, but to choice. He lets them go because staying near him has become dangerous, because loving him has a cost he no longer wants anyone else to pay. So he chooses the loneliness himself. He hands it to himself, wraps it up, and calls it protection.
And the thing about wearing something long enough – a mask, a role, a version of yourself built to survive, is that eventually you stop being able to tell where it ends and you begin. I know that boy. I was that boy. I was optimistic once. Charismatic, people said, though I never quite believed I deserved the word. I loved helping people the way Peter loved it, instinctively, before thinking, like it was just what you did when someone near you was hurting. I smiled easily. Genuinely, I think. Back then.
But somewhere in all that helping, all that showing up for everyone else, I never learned how to hand my own weight to someone. I don’t think anyone ever asked to carry it. And because I was always the one smiling, people assumed there was nothing underneath the smile worth asking about. Why would there be? I looked fine. I looked more than fine. So nobody looked closer, and I never quite figured out how to make them. I wanted to be heard so badly. I think I still do. But wanting to be heard and being able to say the thing that needs hearing are two completely different skills, and somewhere along the way I only ever mastered the first.
Now I feel like the Peter Parker the world forgot. Not because anything dramatic happened. Just because I’ve been quietly disappearing in plain sight for a while now, and nobody noticed the disappearing because I never announced it. I don’t feel much anymore. That’s the honest, uncomfortable truth of it. I’ve gone numb in a way that scares me more than sadness ever did, because at least sadness is a feeling. This is something quieter. Something emptier. I’ll laugh at something, or smile at someone, and there’s this half-second delay where I ask myself – was that real? Or was that just the shape my face knows how to make now? I’ve done the motion so many times I’ve lost the memory of what it felt like before it was a motion.
Some days I feel like I’ve drifted somewhere far off. Not gone, exactly. Just distant. Like I’m floating in some quiet, dark space where sound doesn’t quite reach, and even when people try, when they really try, their voices arrive muffled, delayed, like they’re calling to me from a long way away. I don’t think it’s their fault. I don’t think it’s mine either. I think this is just what happens when you spend long enough being the one who holds things together for everyone else. You forget there was ever a version of you that needed holding too.
Peter’s story doesn’t end in that dark place. That’s the part I keep returning to, even now. The movie isn’t really about how far he falls, it’s about the way back. I don’t know yet what my way back looks like. I don’t know if I’ve even started walking it.
But I’m writing this down, which is more than I’ve said out loud in a long time. Maybe that’s the first small thing. Maybe being heard starts with being willing to speak, even when you’re not sure anyone’s listening yet. I’m still floating. But I’m not sure I want to float forever. There’s a part of this I haven’t said yet, the part that scares me most. It’s that even if someone reached out – a friend, a therapist, someone who really tried, I don’t think I could let them in. Some door in me has quietly shut, and I don’t know when it happened or how to find the handle again. I tell myself no one could bring back the person I used to be, so what’s the point of reaching.
But I sometimes wonder if that thought isn’t the truth. Maybe it’s just the numbness talking, convincing me that the walls are load-bearing when they’re not. Peter never fixes things by doing it all alone. That’s the part I keep forgetting when I tell his story back to myself. The way back, in the end, isn’t a solo mission. Maybe mine isn’t either – even if right now, I can’t quite believe that yet.
Like Spider-Man, I’d rather not reveal the Peter Parker behind this mask.

A response from someone who believes the way back is not a solo mission.
He asked for it to be shared wider, as a forum post and not just left in a small group. So here it is. The reflection above was written by someone who chose to remain anonymous. I am sharing his words without claiming authorship, because I believe they deserve to be heard beyond the small group in which they were originally shared. Before anything else, I want to acknowledge the person behind it. It takes one kind of courage to write something that honest, and another kind to let people read it. Everything above is his. What follows is my own reflection.
I think there’s something we often misunderstand about being a good person. We associate kindness with always being available. We associate love with giving more than we receive. We associate strength with handling everything ourselves. And sometimes, without even realizing it, we start believing that our worth comes from how much we can endure for other people. Peter does this in almost every version of his story. He’s late for the play, late for class, late even for his own birthday, because somebody somewhere needed him more, and somehow he never learns to count himself among the people who need him – Spider-Man 2 (2004)
But perhaps we’ve misunderstood the assignment. You can be kind without making yourself available to everyone, all the time. You can love someone without abandoning yourself in the process. You can be independent and still ask someone to stay. You can be strong and still admit that you’re having a difficult day. And you can put your guard down without handing everyone the keys to your life. None of these are contradictions. They only feel like contradictions because most of us were taught one half of each sentence and never the other.
I think finding the middle ground is one of the hardest things we’ll ever learn, mostly because the extremes are so much easier to understand. Giving everything is simple. Giving nothing is simple too. It’s the in-between that asks something of us every single day: knowing when to say yes and when to say “No”, when to show up and when to rest, when to let someone in and how far.
Solitude is beautiful when you choose it. It becomes painful when you convince yourself that you don’t need anyone. Having people around is beautiful too, but depending entirely on them to regulate your emotions, validate your existence or make you feel worthy can become another kind of prison. Neither one is really freedom. One is a room with no door. The other is a room where somebody else always holds the key. We are social beings. We need connection. We need people who listen, people who understand, people who remind us that we don’t have to figure everything out alone. Even Peter, the most stubborn solo act in the whole city, was never really meant to do this alone. For most of his story there was someone at the kitchen table asking how his day really went, and a best friend in the chair who knew everything and stayed anyway. Spider-Man swings alone. Peter Parker was never meant to live that way.
But we also need to become someone we can return to when nobody is around. On the nights when the phone stays quiet, when no one has noticed, when the people who love us are busy carrying their own weight, we need to be able to sit with ourselves and say, gently, that we did enough today. That it’s okay to be tired. That we are still worth something even when nobody is saying it out loud. Learning to comfort ourselves isn’t a replacement for other people. It’s what keeps us steady while we wait for them, and it’s what stops us from handing our whole sense of worth to whoever happens to be in the room.
Maybe happiness isn’t about becoming completely independent of people. Maybe it isn’t about finding someone who will constantly reassure us either. And maybe it isn’t waiting for us somewhere further down the road, after we’ve fixed everything that’s wrong. A lot of it is already here, in small things we walk past every day: a friend who still texts first, a cup of tea that tastes just right, a silly joke at a lunch table, a morning that didn’t start badly. Peter, at his lowest, in a tiny apartment nobody knows about, stitching his own suit at the table by himself, still gets up and goes out. Not because the world remembers him, but because the city is still worth looking after. And so is he.

Maybe it’s about learning to stand on our own feet while still allowing someone to hold our hand. And perhaps that’s what finding our way back really looks like. Not becoming the person we were before everything happened. Not pretending that nothing hurt us. Not building another version of ourselves that never gets attached, never gets disappointed and never needs anybody. Just becoming someone who can experience life without constantly fighting it. Someone who can give without emptying themselves, who can receive without feeling guilty, who can walk alone without feeling abandoned, and walk alongside someone without losing their identity.
Asking for help is the part most of us are worst at, and I don’t think it’s because we’re proud. I think it’s because we’ve been the dependable one for so long that needing something feels like breaking a promise. But vulnerability isn’t a crack in the mask. It’s taking the mask off for one person, in one room, for one conversation, and finding out that they don’t run. It doesn’t have to be a grand confession. It can be as small as saying “I’m not okay today” and letting that sentence sit there, without rushing to fix it for the other person. There is a difference between protecting your peace and building walls around your entire existence. There is a difference between self-respect and emotional unavailability. I hope we learn to recognize that difference.
There’s a moment near the end of Brand New Day that I keep coming back to. After everything he has lost, after the whole world has forgotten Peter Parker, a little kid in a Spider-Man costume outside the hospital does the web-shooting gesture, sound effects and all, and for a moment Spider-Man notices him. Nobody in that crowd knows who is under the mask. Nobody remembers the boy behind it. And still, that small moment of kindness is the thing that looks most like him. I don’t think kindness was ever the problem. Kindness that forgets to include ourselves is.

So maybe think of me as another Peter Parker, in another universe. Not one who has everything figured out. Not even close. Just one who slowly figured out that you don’t need to have everything figured out to start living. We can still live while the questions are open. We can still believe in people, still be kind, still laugh properly at something, and still take good care of ourselves, all while we are figuring things out. Life doesn’t wait at the door until we’re ready, and I’ve stopped asking it to.
Moreover, to the person behind the mask: I hope you’re doing better. I hope you have people around you who see more than the person who always shows up for everyone else. I hope you eventually realize that you deserve the same kindness you so effortlessly give to others. You wrote that you’re still floating, but that you’re not sure you want to float forever. I want you to know that someone read that line and wanted to reach out a hand. You don’t have to take it today. It will still be there.
I hope you’re doing well under that mask, Peter Parker.

See you in Doomsday. 💚
Get ready for doomsday: https://app.notion.com/p/Doomsday-watch-3dcc425e931c80c68b73edf63c66c788
One last thing, mostly for everyone else reading this. Over giving in the name of kindness is self-sacrifice, and over-empathy without boundaries is self-abandonment. Fighting everything alone, even when you want to ask for help, isn’t always bravery. Sometimes it’s a failure to extend the same self-care, self-love and compassion to yourself that you extend to everyone else. We don’t have to choose between loneliness and complete dependence. We need a little solitude, a little connection, a little independence, a little vulnerability. A little of everything. Because too much of anything, even something beautiful, can become harmful.
P.S. His words remain his, and this response is mine. If any part of his reflection felt familiar, you are not the only one wearing a mask. And maybe check on your friendly neighborhood colleague once in a while. Sometimes the one who always shows up is the one who needs someone to show up for them.
